Page 1 of 2

Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2018 4:07 pm
by omdawe
So i need change my system disk on my QNAP and i can't find the right information somewhere.

What is the best practice?

Turn off my QNAP and take the system disk out and the old system disk and the new disk on my computer and use some clone hard drive software?

Any advice is much appreciated!

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2018 4:50 pm
by storageman
There is no "system" disk as such.
Model, firmware and RAID config?

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2018 9:37 pm
by ssuper2k
If you installed your nas initially as a single disk, the you have 1 system disk

If you installed your nas initially as a raid 1, the you have 2 'system' disks

If you installed your nas initially as a raid 5, the you have at least 3 'system' disks

-
I agree, there's no Qnap documentation on how to replace/restore these..

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Jul 04, 2018 4:50 pm
by omdawe
I got a QNAP TS-851 with 8 disks but i installed the QNAP with 1 disk first so the main system is only on one disk. So Disk 1!

And this is the one i want to switch out!.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Jul 04, 2018 5:18 pm
by storageman
You've lost us.
What RAID config do you have??

I repeat, there is no "system" disk as such.
There is a "system" volume that holds default shares and apps.
Then the OS or system is a striped mirrored partition across all disks regardless of the RAID configuration.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2018 5:23 am
by ssuper2k
@omdawe:
Turn off the NAS, remove/extract that disk, see if NAS still boots-up.
If it does, then you have the system (volume) in more disks.
.

I have a tvs671, with raid 5 (x4), then added a raid 0 (2 disks) and it can't boot if I start the NAS with just the raid 0 disks.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2018 5:55 am
by Don
The best practice is to use RAID on all disks. There is no easy way to swap out a single disk especially the one that was used to build your system.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Tue Jul 10, 2018 4:57 pm
by storageman
ssuper2k wrote:@omdawe:
Turn off the NAS, remove/extract that disk, see if NAS still boots-up.
If it does, then you have the system (volume) in more disks.
.

I have a tvs671, with raid 5 (x4), then added a raid 0 (2 disks) and it can't boot if I start the NAS with just the raid 0 disks.
That should not be the case.
Do you mean not see the default shares and apps or not boot at all?
The (system) volume DOES NOT need to be present for a Qnap to boot.

I find this very hard to believe.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2018 2:59 am
by jeramie
i've got the same issue.

When i first got my TS-1635, i only had a single drive to play with and i popped it in not knowing that the nas was going to put system stuff onto that drive that couldn't be moved. pretty stupid of me yes, but also a poor design on qnaps part to not have a utility to move this system volume if needed.

Now i have a raid 5 volume as well as a couple single drive volumes, in addition to that single drive volume which contains my system file. I'd be very curious to see what options are available as well.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2018 9:40 pm
by storageman
jeramie wrote:i've got the same issue.

When i first got my TS-1635, i only had a single drive to play with and i popped it in not knowing that the nas was going to put system stuff onto that drive that couldn't be moved. pretty stupid of me yes, but also a poor design on qnaps part to not have a utility to move this system volume if needed.

Now i have a raid 5 volume as well as a couple single drive volumes, in addition to that single drive volume which contains my system file. I'd be very curious to see what options are available as well.
Hang on, what makes you say that?
There is enable Home Folder that can be changed to a different volume (with care)
There is migrate apps in app centre.
There is recreate default shares.
There is set media folder.

Actually it's not that difficult but clearly people need to plan carefully.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2018 10:56 pm
by Don
Not all apps provide the option to be moved.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Jul 11, 2018 11:01 pm
by storageman
Don wrote:Not all apps provide the option to be moved.
Correct, but those without the move option can be reinstalled on the new volume.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Wed Sep 19, 2018 12:06 am
by kimarild
Hello

My question is not identical to this, but in the same ballpark, so I will take my chances.

I started my NAS with only one disk, so that system and media is on the same drive.
I would now like to add one SSD to my Qnap, and separate System and Media on separate drives.

Here comes my question.
Can I just pull out my old drive, put in my new SSD, reinstall the hole system on new SSD.
Then powerdown, insert my old drive which contain system and media.
*pray it will boot on my SSD drive*
Then just delete all system stuff from the drive I want to work as media-only?

Yes or No answer would be nice :D

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Sat Sep 22, 2018 7:29 am
by P3R
kimarild wrote:Can I just pull out my old drive, put in my new SSD, reinstall the hole system on new SSD.
Then powerdown, insert my old drive which contain system and media.
*pray it will boot on my SSD drive*
Then just delete all system stuff from the drive I want to work as media-only?

Yes or No answer would be nice :D
No.

Please stop double posting.

Re: Replacing System disk best practice!

Posted: Sun Dec 30, 2018 12:40 am
by renamart
I've same issue of kimarild, anybody can show what could be the way to do it? (Separating media and system)